In my initial post, on how Austrians strive for a self-comforting irrelevancy on climate change, I copied my chief comment to Stephan Kinsella.
I copy below my other posts and some of the remarks I was responding to on Stephan`s thread, including the one that I was unable to post - for some reason I am trying to figure out (but that Stephan tells me was not a result of moderation by him; I note my full apology, as stated in my update to my preceding post):
This is last version of the comment that I tried to post several times:
method fan:
[my first attempt apparently failed to post, so apologies if this shows up twice]
- "You are insofar wrong, that not only this "data" is analysed but it is also used to "predict" the future of reality by using it in simulations!"
You miss my criticism of Dr. Hayden`s refusal to examine facts about ongoing melting in Antarctica, but of course I do NOT disagree with you that current and paleo data can be used to "predict" the future.
But of course a scientific understanding of the world, and information - in this case, both about the past and current trends of climate inputs - certainly can give us useful information about what the future may hold in store for us.
"There is no sound experimental proof that human activity-emitted carbon dioxide is the cause for some sort of global warming."
Nicely phrased; there of course plenty of experimental proof that carbon dioxide is an atmospheric warming agent, but no experimental proof that it is "the" cause for any global warming.
While we are now running such a global experiment - one that started centuries ago and will not be played out for centuries hence and is, for all intents and purposes irreversible - and thus cannot, in the Popperian sense, even be considered an "experiment".
Whether our ramping up of the experiment is prudent or principled are entirely different questions, and properly the subject of much discussion.
- "These guesses remind one of the idea that rain dances are the cause for rain."
I`m tempted to make a comeback, but surely you realize your flip comparison is entirely inapropos.
Here`s hoping for more sincere discourse.
TT