Free Capitalist Network - Community Archive
Mises Community Archive
An online community for fans of Austrian economics and libertarianism, featuring forums, user blogs, and more.

101 Reasons You Might be a Keynesian if....

This post has 9 Replies | 3 Followers

Top 500 Contributor
Posts 104
Points 1,585
TheNcredibleEgg Posted: Fri, Jul 9 2010 3:12 AM

Hi, this is my first post on this site. This thread was recently completely on the IMDB politics website by myself and several other posters, and I thought it might be appreciated here. (It's about to be cycled out of existence there so this is an attempt by me to save it too.)  Some of the ways are tongue-in-cheek, some are serious. Please amend (for accuracy), edit, or add (or even ignore) at will. Thanks.


You might be a Keynesian if:

1) Instead of giving your kids allowances, you give them weekly stimulus checks.

2) Instead of running out of black ink all the time, you are constantly having to buy more green ink.

3) Instead of encouraging your kids to get after school jobs to help out, you tell them instead to go around town, breaking windows and vandalizing businesses. That will really stimulate the local economy.

4) You bitterly try to stave off winter every year. Outdoor air conditioning, heat lamps in the garden. Whatever is takes. You must keep the tulip bulbs growing, dammit!

5) You have a kid who suffers from a severe immune deficiency. He lives in a bubble. You call him Economy Boy.

6) You don't believe in hangovers. Instead, you just keep on drinking and avoid them altogether.

7) Grandpa one day says "a penny saved is a penny earned" and you tell your wife that dad must be going senile.

8) Christmas is not the big shopping holiday in your family. It's the 4th of July because you believe shopping is everyone's patriotic duty.

9) Natural disasters to be welcomed. Nothing stimulates the economy better than rebuilding in the aftermath.

10) Your wife asked you if you would balance the checkbook, and you just stare at her confused and completely dumbfounded, thinking she must be speaking a foreign language.

11) You think the gold standard is a special, elite level credit card. 12) You spend your days filling out credit card applications instead of job applications.

13) You invested your money in helium instead of gold because that's something the economy always needs.

14) Your wife says that you are getting a bit of a gut. You tell her it's just healthy inflation.

15) You cannoy decide whether GWB or Obama is the greatest President of all-time.

16) When people complain about illegal immigrants, you nod in agreement, and say, "Yup, all those damn Austrians need to go."

17) You think that the gold standard can never work because there is 'not enough gold' for all of the printed up fiat currency out there.

18) You believe that the federal reserve saved the economy and is not the primary cause of our financial problems

19) You think that the federal reserve is the federal government

20) The government must go into greater debt because spending money stimulates the economy even though you owe what you have in debt plus interests to the federal reserve

21) The great depression was caused by free market economics

22) Higher prices means that government induced inflation makes a item more valuable at stores

23) Your money at the bank will never loose its value

24) Government hiring people shows that the economy is getting better

25) You get a foreclosure notice in the mail, shrug, and just forward it to the government - not giving it a second thought.

26) You don't understand why anyone would hesitate to accept the dollar bills that you ran off on the copier.

27) You decide that it must be due to a lack of consumer confidence and that the solution is to run off even more dollar bills on the copier.

28) You believe that government spending is one of the largest in the economy and that this creates jobs, maintains the country and helps individuals.

 29) You serve on a jury where the accused is standing trial for counterfeiting. The judge asks if you've reached a verdict after the trial, and you scratch you head, confused, then stand and say, "Your Honor, could you please explain to me again what crime that man is charged with committing? I just don't get it."

30) Whenever anyone points out the negative long-term effects of something you do, you respond, "In the long run, we're all dead." Never mind our children.

31) You consider the New Deal to be a success even though the unemployment rate remained in the double digits until 1941.

 32) Despite what happened in Argentina, you still believe we can spend our way to prosperity.

33) You equate money with wealth: the more money in the economy, the more wealthy we are. Period.

34) A thief picks your pocket and makes off with $200 and you think this is okay because the thief will undoubtedly buy clothes, booze, and entertainment, thus stimulating the economy.

35) You consider 9/11, Katrina and the Gulf Oil Spill as major reconstruction opportunities, and that doing nothing is the right thing.

36) Whenever applying for credit, you take your kids with you, and ask, "Well, kids, what do ya think? Can ole' dad afford the new car?" Then you tell the kids where to sign.

37) You consider the "Fear the Boom and Bust" video on YouTube blasphemy, and have petitioned repeatedly to have the video marked as vulgar.

38) You lose your job and your wife says, "We'll just have to tighten our belts and get by." Stunned by her words, you file for divorce the next day, citing "irreconcilable differences."

39) Your kid asks for a piggy bank, and you decide, right then and there, it's time for a life lesson so you punish the kid severely for wanting to save.

40) You can't comprehend why Zimbabwe is poor even though they have all of this printed money in circulation since more printed money = greater wealth.

41) You believe that Germans during the Weimer Republic carrying wheel barrels of money to buy a loaf of bread is a conspiracy theory.

42) After losing your job and your wife, you decide the rest of the family needs a little distraction so you send your kids out in the neighborhood to beat up on the weaker kids. The distraction works nicely, as expected, and it stimulates the economy too!

43) You are strangely satisfied with the thought of Lindsay Lohan in jail. That's something Austrians and Keynesian can both find mutual agreement in.

44) Not a single one of your economic theories has ever even come close to working in practice.

45) Deflation is a dirty word in your household. So much so that you threaten to rinse your kids' mouths out with soap if they ever say it.

 46) You played a game of Monopoly five years ago where you doubled as the banker. That game is still ongoing today. Your opponent controls most of the properties, but you have simply expanded the money supply countless times over to pay off your debts like any good central banker does.

47) When grandpa says things like "back in my day candy bars used to cost a nickel. A nickel!" you just smile and shrug, failing to grasp the real implications of that fact.

48) If anyone points out the ineffectiveness of a stimulus package, you respond that the government just didn't spend enough.

49) You always think that we're in a liquidity trap.

50) You live in the United States or most any other country because, let's face it, whether we like it or not, "We are all Keynesians now."

51) You don't understand why mal-investments are considered such a negative for the economy. Except for the obvious fact most people cannot spell, mall investments are great. We always need more malls.

52) (If divorced) You promise many free things to your kids compared to stingy mom telling them things like "there are no free lunches in life." All in an attempt to win over your kids' affectations and be elected favorite parent.

53) Your economic theory is based in criticism of Say's Law debunked in the early 19th century, just rehashed in an era where there was war so the government had an excuse to spend and expand.

54) Your investment plan is solely based upon an aggregate understanding of day-trading trends, never mind long term trend in the economy based in logic, just rebuild your model every week or so.

55) Your think "aggregate demand" or "the price level" is a real world concept, as if the same agent shopped for everything in the whole world or the average anything being an accurate measurement of anything.

56) Your argument against the capital structure is that it's not based in made up mythical statistics - like happiness level

57) You think the GDP is the same thing as long term stable production output, even though Keynesians themselves spend time criticizing GDP.

58) You have no concept of capital theory. None. What. So. Ever.

59) You don't understand that the government is not a deity, you don't understand that it has inherit flaws and incentive structures. (And even when you win a noble prize for pointing this out in the private sector, later on go into the public sector to work and see these problems to a larger extent, you think the solution is to fix the bigger problem, not to eliminate the bigger problem and focus on the smaller one)

60) You believe in animal spirits. Literary. That humans are possessed by them. 

61) Your grade school kid has to do an oral presentation about how an economy works, and asks for help. You give him a pack of chewing gum and tell him to blow bubbles to demonstrate best. That they eventually pop, no matter. Just keep blowing bubbles to get a solid A.

62) When preparing the family budget for the upcoming year, you don't use salary as a starting point, but rather salary and available credit.

63) When you finally succumb to your debt and file for bankruptcy, you tell the judge that if you can just get another credit card, all your problems would be solved.

64) When paying for something, and asked "Will that be debit or credit?" You reply there is no i in debt. Huh? The cashier stares back, confused. You try to explain your not so clever word play, before finally sheepishly saying, "credit, of course."

65) A neighbor of yours gives you an old wheelbarrow as a gift and alludes to the fact that you will be in dire need of it one day. You shrug and thank them. They always were a little odd. The family emigrated from Germany back in the day and you knew they were rather poor since they never spent any money. Perhaps a wheelbarrow was all they could afford?

66) Well, well, well, here we stand at #66 out of a promised 101, and I am plum out of ideas. Let's call the gap an unfunded mandate. What to do? What to do? Well, that's an easy problem for the Keynesians. Just turn on the printing presses and warm up the helicopters, if necessary. Let the magic of inflation do its job.

*4 hours later*

101) <-- See, see. 101 promised, 101 delivered. The magic of inflation. All is well. Nevermind the fact that the 101 doesn't seem quite up to snuff somehow. All that matters is the mandate was fulfilled. If it doesn't buy as much as you expected back in the day, well, your expectations were just too high. That is all. (And oh btw...that wheelbarrow sure does come in handy.)

  • | Post Points: 65
Top 500 Contributor
Posts 212
Points 4,330
Aquila replied on Fri, Jul 9 2010 8:26 AM

This is great! Going to forward this to some friends of mind who are Keynesians. :-)

  • | Post Points: 5
Top 150 Contributor
Posts 785
Points 13,445

16) When people complain about illegal immigrants, you nod in agreement, and say, "Yup, all those damn Austrians need to go."

38) You lose your job and your wife says, "We'll just have to tighten our belts and get by." Stunned by her words, you file for divorce the next day, citing "irreconcilable differences."

41) You believe that Germans during the Weimer Republic carrying wheel barrels of money to buy a loaf of bread is a conspiracy theory.

43) You are strangely satisfied with the thought of Lindsay Lohan in jail. That's something Austrians and Keynesian can both find mutual agreement in.


Welcome good sir!

"Lo! I am weary of my wisdom, like the bee that hath gathered too much honey; I need hands outstretched to take it." -Thus Spake Zarathustra
  • | Post Points: 20
Top 500 Contributor
Posts 177
Points 2,860
Naevius replied on Fri, Jul 9 2010 2:31 PM

While they are ALL genius, my personal favorites are 65, 66, and 67-er!...I mean 101. 101 was what I meant.

Welcome to the forums, my friend!

  • | Post Points: 5
Not Ranked
Posts 18
Points 290

102) I am a bond vigilante and I want my 101 back!

  • | Post Points: 45
Not Ranked
Posts 3
Points 60
B.Stone replied on Fri, Jul 9 2010 3:49 PM

Good stuff...thanks for sharing!

We all have our moments. 

  • | Post Points: 5
Top 500 Contributor
Posts 104
Points 1,585

Oooh yeah, bond vigilantes. Good one.


In addition to yours, there could be a 16b:

"When people say vigilante justice should be punished harshly, you nod in agreement, and say, "Hell yeah, especially those damn bond vigilantes. They deserve the chair."

  • | Post Points: 20
Top 25 Contributor
Posts 3,113
Points 60,515
Esuric replied on Fri, Jul 9 2010 9:09 PM

When you believe that the demand for commodities is the demand for labor...

"If we wish to preserve a free society, it is essential that we recognize that the desirability of a particular object is not sufficient justification for the use of coercion."

  • | Post Points: 35
Top 500 Contributor
Posts 268
Points 5,220

60) You believe in animal spirits. Literary. That humans are possessed by them. 


That one reminded me of a person I knew who claimed that he could 'cure' just about any disease by 'exorcizing' out the 'deamons' that caused them....


If you preface everything you say with the phrase 'studies have shown...' people will believe anything you say no matter how ridiculous. Studies have shown this works 87.64% of the time.
  • | Post Points: 5
Not Ranked
Posts 63
Points 1,035

I like the debit joke. also number 16 was good too.

Welcome to the forums :D

Empty your mind, be formless. Shapeless, like water. If you put water into a cup, it becomes the cup.You put it in a teapot it becomes the teapot. Now, water can flow or it can crash. Be water my friend. -Bruce Lee
  • | Post Points: 5
Page 1 of 1 (10 items) | RSS